November 12, 2019

Over a Utah winter, the team at Gunthers Heating, Cooling, Plumbing and Electrical sees a lot of heating systems. We work hard to keep them running, even when a furnace has seen better days. But a failing furnace is more than an inconvenience. When it quits during a cold snap in American Fork, it can leave your family uncomfortable and, in some cases, unsafe. The signs below can help you tell when it is time to stop repairing and start planning a replacement.

1. Your Furnace Is Getting Old

Most furnaces last 15 to 20 years, and a well-maintained unit may reach 20 to 25. As a furnace ages, its parts wear out, it runs less efficiently, and it needs more frequent tune-ups. If yours is past the 15-year mark, it is worth planning ahead rather than waiting for a breakdown. Not sure how old it is? Look for the manufacture date on the unit, or call the manufacturer with the model and serial number. Turn the furnace off and let it cool before you check.

2. Repairs Keep Adding Up

Our technicians can repair almost any heating system, but if you are calling for service several times a season, the repair bills are telling you something. A common rule of thumb is that if a repair costs more than half the price of a new furnace, replacement is usually the smarter investment. Repeated breakdowns also mean repeated stretches in a cold house.

3. Your Energy Bills Keep Climbing

Furnaces lose efficiency over the years. Regular maintenance slows that decline but cannot stop it. If your heating bills are climbing, especially during winters that are not unusually cold, your furnace may be working overtime. 

4. Strange Noises or Smells

A little noise during operation is normal. But popping, rattling, screeching, booming, clanking, or humming can point to loose components, a failing motor or pulley, or problems inside the system. A tune-up can fix some of these issues, but persistent or worsening noise often means the furnace is working too hard and nearing the end of its life. Have a technician inspect it so you know for sure. 

Smells matter just as much. If you smell gas or a rotten-egg odor, leave your home immediately. Do not flip light switches, use your phone inside, or operate any appliances, since a spark could ignite the gas. Once you are outside, call your gas utility or emergency services (911). Stay out until a professional confirms it is safe to go back in. Other unusual furnace smells, such as burning or musty odors, should also be checked by a technician. 

5. Uneven Heating Around the Home

If some rooms feel warm while others stay cold, or rooms never reach the temperature you set, your furnace may not be distributing heat properly. Rooms farthest from the unit are usually the first to suffer. A technician can tell you whether the cause is something simple like a failing blower or ductwork problem, or a larger issue with the furnace itself.

6. Short Cycling or Constant Thermostat Adjustments

A healthy furnace turns on when the temperature drops below your thermostat setting and turns off once it is reached. If your furnace switches on and off frequently (short cycling), runs nearly nonstop, or you find yourself adjusting the thermostat because the house will not stay warm, the first step is to find the cause. Common causes include a dirty air filter, restricted airflow, thermostat issues, a faulty flame sensor, or a furnace that is the wrong size for your home. Start by checking that your filter is clean and your vents and registers are open and unblocked. If the problem continues, have a technician diagnose it. Short cycling does not mean the furnace needs to be replaced, and many causes can be corrected with a repair or adjustment. Left unaddressed, it can increase energy use and put extra wear on the system. Carrier’s short-cycling guidance

7. Soot Around the Furnace or Registers

Soot around the furnace, vent connections, or nearby registers can mean the furnace is not venting combustion byproducts properly. Soot is not the same as ordinary household dust, which has many everyday causes and is not a sign of a furnace problem on its own. If you notice black or dark soot near a fuel-burning appliance or its vent, stop using the furnace if you can do so without delay and call a technician promptly. If a CO alarm sounds or anyone in the home feels unwell, follow the emergency steps in sign 9 instead.

8. A Yellow Furnace Flame

A healthy gas furnace burns with a steady blue flame. A flame that stays yellow can indicate incomplete combustion, which can produce carbon monoxide, an odorless, tasteless, and dangerous gas. A brief flicker at startup is not a concern, but if the flame stays yellow, contact us right away and have the furnace inspected before continuing to use it. If a CO alarm sounds or anyone in the home has symptoms such as headaches, nausea, or dizziness, get everyone outside and call 911, as described in sign 9.

9. Unexplained Illness in the Household

Unexplained nausea, headaches, dizziness, or fatigue among family members can be a sign of a carbon monoxide (CO) leak. Over time, a heat exchanger can crack from repeated heating and cooling, allowing carbon monoxide into the home. This is most common in older furnaces but can also affect newer ones that were poorly installed.

If a CO alarm sounds or you suspect CO exposure, get everyone outside into fresh air immediately and call 911. Stay outside until emergency responders tell you it is safe to re-enter. Once the situation is cleared, have a qualified technician inspect your furnace before using it again. As a safeguard, install working CO alarms on every level of your home and outside each sleeping area. See CPSC guidance and Trane’s gas-smell guidance .

10. Dry Air in the Home

Dry winter air is common and does not mean your furnace is failing. If the air in your home feels unusually dry, or humidity has dropped suddenly, start by assessing the cause. Check your indoor humidity level, look for air leaks that let dry outdoor air in, and have a technician confirm the heating system is running properly. Dry air can aggravate sinus and allergy problems. If humidity stays low, a whole-home humidifier that is compatible with your existing system can improve comfort.

Repair or Replace? Questions to Ask

Seeing one or two of the signs above does not automatically mean you need a new furnace. These questions can help you decide.

  • Is it safe? If the furnace is releasing carbon monoxide and cannot be repaired, replacement is the only safe choice.
  • How old is it, and how well does it run? Age matters, but performance matters more. A well-kept older furnace can outlast a neglected newer one.
  • How efficient is it? Furnace efficiency is measured by AFUE (annual fuel utilization efficiency). If your furnace is running well below the efficiency of today’s models, you may save money by upgrading. High-efficiency models commonly reach 95% AFUE or higher.
  • Is this a repeat problem? If the same furnace keeps breaking down, repair bills may be costing you more than a replacement would.
  • Which option saves more in the long run? A new furnace costs more up front, and whether it costs less to operate depends on the efficiency of your current furnace, the efficiency of the new model, fuel prices, local weather, and your home. To estimate payback, ask your installer for an estimated annual heating-cost saving based on your home, then compare it with the net installed cost after any rebates or incentives. Ask about manufacturer rebates and utility incentives that may lower that cost.

Try these low-cost fixes first. Replacing weatherstripping, sealing leaky ducts, and adding insulation can reduce the workload on an older furnace. A professional energy audit can show where your home is losing heat. It is also worth asking the manufacturer or a technician whether a replacement part could solve the problem instead of a whole new unit.

Get a second opinion. If the first technician recommends replacement, get two or three estimates before you decide.

Furnace Replacement in American Fork, UT

If your furnace is showing these signs, our licensed technicians can inspect it and give you an honest recommendation on whether to repair or replace. Gunthers has served Utah County families for over 100 years. We handle furnace repair, heating maintenance, and furnace installation, and we offer financing options to help make a new system more manageable. Along with American Fork, we also provide Lehi furnace installation and Orem furnace installation for homeowners across northern Utah County. Contact Gunthers today to schedule an inspection. 

company icon
Categories: